Recreating Favorite Flavors with Vegan Ingredients


As an omnivore eater and cook, I was always one to think a lot about the flavors and textures of food, and to follow my instincts when it came to seasoning. Still, I found that I relied a lot on already flavor-packed animal products (e.g. parmesan cheese, smoked and salted meats, etc.) to add depth to my food. In my book, “bacon” was a flavor, as was “seafood stock,” “beefiness,” and “cheesiness.”

Now that I’ve cut animal products out of my diet, though, I’ve come to think about and understand flavor in a totally different way. This shift was gradual, but the ultimate turning point for me, I think, was after an absolutely incredible meal at the vegetable-focused, vegan restaurant Vedge in Philadelphia. Two of the most memorable plates I had that night were Honshimeji Beach Style stew and Saffron Cauliflower Soup. The stew tasted exactly like a New England seafood boil, while the soup was reminiscent of a fish stew I’d had in a little waterside inn in Corsica years ago. What was so remarkable was that both dishes somehow captured what I had previously understood to be the taste of the ocean, without using a single artificial flavor or meat substitute. I realized that it wasn’t the flavor of “seafood stock” that I had always loved, but the combination of various herbs and spices, in this case brininess with Old Bay, or saffron with white wine and fennel.  Once mixed with those perfectly balanced seasonings, the chewy honshimeji mushrooms were hardly distinguishable from fresh clams, or the cauliflower from tender white fish.


After this discovery, I began to look at my favorite animal-product flavors through a new lens, breaking them down into their composite parts. Parmesan cheese, for example, became not simply “salty-cheesiness,” but salt, nuttiness, earthiness (umami), and a little tang. Once I was able to deconstruct the flavors in this way, it became relatively easy to put them back together using plant-based products. Nuttiness, for example, was easily achieved with toasted almonds; earthiness/umami with nutritional yeast; and the tang with a squeeze of fresh lemon. All three together made for a surprisingly delicious pasta topping. (Of course I’m far from the first to think of this. Parmela, for example, offers a wonderful all-natural vegan parmesan that seems to be based on the same principals.)


Through lots of trial and error, I’ve so far found and/or developed several easy vegan cheats to naturally capture the essence of some of my favorite taste profiles from my omnivore days. The ratios vary depending on the other ingredients in your dish, so I encourage you to play around and experiment! In the weeks to come, I’ll be featuring these tricks in some of my recipe posts.

-Mediterranean-style seafood broth: saffron, fennel, tomato, white wine

-American-style seafood broth: Old Bay spice, corn or corn broth, saffron

-Western-style beef broth: dried mushrooms (especially porcinis), soy sauce, red wine(optional), thyme(optional)

-Asian-style beef broth: dry shitake and/or porcini mushrooms, soy, five spice(optional)

-Chicken broth: carrots, parsnips, leeks, browned button mushrooms and/or light dried mushrooms (e.g. chanterelles), nutritional yeast

-Cream/bechamel sauce: cashew cream, nutmeg, nutritional yeast

-Bacon flavor: liquid smoke, salt, brown sugar

-Parmesan cheese: toasted almonds or pine nuts, salt, nutritional yeast, a squeeze of lemon

-Cheddar cheese: Miso paste, mustard, nutritional yeast

Readers, any good cheats I’m missing?


10 thoughts on “Recreating Favorite Flavors with Vegan Ingredients

  1. Thanks for your comments Rosebud and Ani. It’s really a lot of fun–like figuring out a puzzle–when you start trying to recreate flavors with vegan ingredients. Let me know if you come across any tasty combos I missed!

  2. I’ve read and heard a bit about “Nutritional Yeast” as a substitute for cheese. Is it all that easy to get…and since yeast is one of those products that’s probably typically used sparingly, let’s say in making bread, is it really healthy to be eating much larger quantities of it? What are the side effects, if any, of eating “a lot” of Nutritional Yeast. (I assume using it on pasta as the equivalent of parmesan qualifies as “a lot” vs. maybe a tsp or so for making bread…?)

    Then again, I will readily admit I know nothing about this ingredient. 🙂

    • Hi Carol. Great question! I also knew nothing about nutritional yeast before I went vegan, and now it is a staple in my diet. You can get it at most large grocery stores, and at any health food store. Nutritional yeast is completely inactive and has been cooked, so it’s very different from the type of yeast you would use to make bread. Given that I eat A LOT of it (my husband once caught me eating it straight out of the canister …), I’ve scoured the internet several times and have not found any articles that even suggest that it could be associated with heaIth risks. Readers, if you’ve heard otherwise, let me know!

      Everything I’ve read says it’s highly nutritious and very good for you. It’s packed with protein and vitamins, particularly B-12 and B-6 which are otherwise very hard, if not impossible, for vegans to get in their diet. A serving size of nutritional yeast is 1.5 tablespoons, and I can tell you that many vegans probably consume at least that much on a daily basis without any problems. Here’s a little article I found written by a registered dietician with more info:

      • Hmmm. After reading the article, I see there is a difference between Nutritional Yeast and Brewer’s Yeast. Brewer’s Yeast apparently has more chromium and can lower blood sugar and interact with medications. It doesn’t say anything about whether Nutritional Yeast would do that…

        I think I’ll hold off on taking the Nutritional Yeast plunge for now. I’m taking a daily B6/B12 supplement, so I should be covered for B vitamin intake. 🙂

        Thank you for sharing this information!!

  3. I love this post, especially the “cheddar cheese” ingredients. That actually sounds like it would be pretty close to the original flavor!

    Also, It looks like wordpress somehow wiped out my followers (I now have 0!) I noticed you were following before, if you’d still like to get updates, please re-follow again. I’m sorry for the hassle!

    • Hi Ting! Thanks for your kind words.

      What a bummer about WordPress wiping out your followers! I just tried to re-follow you, but it looks like your blog has been turned to private somehow…Maybe once you switch it back to public, your followers will show up again?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s